From his formative years in Habsburg Trieste to his journalistic and diplomatic career and his studies of Italian history, the lecture traced the personal, political and intellectual journey of a controversial twentieth-century figure, exploring the relationship between national identity, the history of Italy's eastern borderlands and the city's collective memory.
The life of Attilio Tamaro, a Trieste-born historian, journalist and diplomat, his progression from irredentism to nationalism and fascism, his views on the Adriatic question and his relationship with his native city were the focus of the lecture “Attilio Tamaro. Portrait of a Triestine Nationalist”, delivered on Friday 13 November by Luigi Fattorini, a scholar of contemporary history, at the headquarters of the “Società Internazionale di divulgazione Manlio Cecovini” Cultural Association in Trieste.
The event provided an opportunity to explore the life of an intellectual who, despite making a significant contribution to the historiography of Trieste and Italy, occupies a relatively marginal place in the city's collective memory today. Fattorini presented a nuanced portrait of a complex figure whose political convictions were often radical, without seeking to celebrate him, distinguishing the value of his historical scholarship from the ideological positions that shaped his life.
Born in Trieste in 1884 into a family of Istrian origin, Tamaro grew up amid the national tensions that characterised the city in the late nineteenth century, when it was still part of the Austro-Hungarian Empire. After attending the Dante Alighieri Gymnasium, he studied at the universities of Vienna, Innsbruck and Graz, graduating in 1906. From an early age, his interest in art history and archaeology was intertwined with a conception of culture closely linked to the affirmation of Italian national identity, setting him apart from the democratic and socialist strands of Triestine irredentism.
After working in Istria, where he dealt with archives and artistic heritage, he returned to Trieste and began his journalistic career, contributing to L'Indipendente and Il Piccolo. In 1910, he became secretary of the Università Popolare (People's University), organising lectures and cultural initiatives that helped foster patriotic sentiment in a political environment marked by tensions between Italian liberals, socialists and the Slovene community.
The First World War marked a decisive turning point. In 1914, Tamaro left Trieste for the Kingdom of Italy, where he took part in pro-intervention propaganda. Following a brief period of military service, he was sent to Paris to support Italian territorial claims in the Adriatic, countering the diplomatic and propaganda activities of Yugoslav representatives.
This experience gave rise to an extensive body of journalistic and historical writing devoted to Venezia Giulia and Dalmatia. Fattorini examined Tamaro's political outlook, according to which Italian ascendancy in the eastern Adriatic was essential to strengthening the country's position as a European power. This perspective placed greater emphasis on the Latin and Italian cultural tradition than on the linguistic and ethnic composition of local populations, particularly in Dalmatia, where Italians constituted a minority.
These convictions brought him into conflict with figures such as Gaetano Salvemini and Leonida Bissolati, who favoured an understanding with the South Slavs and opposed the extensive annexation of Dalmatia. Their differences intensified after the war, when Tamaro strongly opposed the 1920 Treaty of Rapallo, regarding Italy's territorial gains as insufficient, particularly concerning Fiume and Dalmatia, and supported the most uncompromising positions of Adriatic nationalism.
Unable to establish a stable position in Trieste's public life, he gradually moved to Rome, where he embraced fascism before the Italian Nationalist Association merged with the National Fascist Party in 1923. Fattorini linked this decision to Tamaro's distrust of liberal institutions, which he considered incapable of ensuring political stability and resisting the advance of Bolshevism. He regarded fascism as a means of fulfilling a vision of national greatness that, in his view, the Risorgimento, the liberal state and victory in the Great War had failed to achieve fully.
His adherence to fascism did not, however, mean that his relationship with the regime was free from conflict.Through his contributions to publications such as Il Popolo d'Italia and Gerarchia, Tamaro developed his own vision of foreign policy, focusing on the balance of power in the Danubian region following the dissolution of the Austro-Hungarian Empire. Among other positions, he supported the union of Austria with Germany in exchange for territorial guarantees for Italy, the revision of the peace treaties in Hungary's favour, and the dismantling of the unified Yugoslav state. These views initially found little support, even within fascist circles.
In the late 1920s, he embarked on a diplomatic career that took him to Hamburg, Helsinki and, from 1935, Bern. These appointments also revealed the tension between his political ambitions and the responsibilities he actually held. During his years in Switzerland, he expressed frustration at being far removed from the principal centres of political decision-making.
One particularly significant episode explored during the lecture concerned the end of his diplomatic career in 1943. Tamaro had supported Camillo Castiglioni, a Jewish entrepreneur from Trieste, by issuing a letter of recommendation in connection with a business venture in Switzerland. When the affair became public, it attracted criticism from the most radically antisemitic elements of the fascist movement. Although Tamaro was not entirely free from certain prejudices widespread in the political culture of the time, he had not supported the racial legislation introduced in 1938. He defended his actions, maintaining that he had acted in the interests of an Italian citizen. His refusal to retract his position contributed to his dismissal from his diplomatic post and the loss of his National Fascist Party membership.
The fall of fascism and the events of 8 September 1943 marked another turning point in his personal life. A committed monarchist, Tamaro sharply criticised Victor Emmanuel III and the Badoglio government, but did not join the Italian Social Republic. After the war, he returned to the question of Italy's eastern border, supporting Italian territorial claims to Venezia Giulia and Istria and continuing to believe that the border established by the Treaty of Rapallo could be preserved. According to Fattorini, this position illustrated the gap between Tamaro's convictions and the political realities of the time.
In his later years, he devoted himself primarily to reconstructing Italian political history, publishing Due anni di storia(Two Years of History), covering the period 1943–1945, and Vent'anni di storia (Twenty Years of History), focusing on the fascist era. These works also reflected his disillusionment with republican Italy and the party-political system, which he accused of placing particular interests above those of the nation. Tamaro died in 1956.
Particular attention was devoted to his historical scholarship and his monumental Storia di Trieste (History of Trieste), published in 1924, a major reference work distinguished by the breadth and richness of its documentation, although characterised by a strongly nationalist interpretation of the city's history. Fattorini recalled that Tamaro's contribution to the understanding of local history had also been acknowledged by scholars who did not share his political views, including Giulio Cervani.
Indeed, Tamaro's relationship with Trieste was one of the central themes of the concluding reflections. He remained deeply attached to the city culturally and emotionally, while gradually distancing himself from it personally and politically. His decision to settle in Rome, his uncompromising character and his difficulties in finding a place within public life, together with his adherence to fascism, all contributed to his diminished presence in the city's collective memory.
The discussion with the audience provided an opportunity to explore further the relationship between Italian identity, local identity and cultural diversity in the eastern Adriatic. Particular attention was given to Dalmatia's complex history, where Italian and Venetian culture coexisted for centuries with a predominantly Slavic population, and to the transformations brought about by the rise of nationalism during the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. The discussion highlighted the importance of distinguishing cultural affiliation from linguistic and national identity, rather than interpreting complex historical realities through political categories that emerged in later periods.
The discussion also addressed the relationship between Trieste's tradition of municipal autonomy, its Italian cultural heritage and the city's Central European legacy. Fattorini observed that Tamaro tended to interpret earlier expressions of municipal autonomy in national terms, even though they had originally arisen from different historical circumstances. At the same time, he emphasised the importance of recognising the historical presence of Italian culture in Trieste without overlooking the German, Slovene and wider Central European influences that helped shape the city's identity. The discussion also touched on bilingualism and knowledge of the Slovene language.
The lecture thus offered a portrait of an intellectual whose life reflected many of the tensions and contradictions of twentieth-century Triestine and Italian history. As Fattorini emphasised, Tamaro is not a figure whose political choices require uncritical rehabilitation, but one who deserves to be known and studied in order to gain a deeper understanding of irredentism, nationalism, fascism and the history of Italy's eastern borderlands.
WATCH THE GALLERY