The relationship between humans and animals, the cultural roots of anthropocentrism and the role of literature in rethinking our place in the natural world were at the heart of a lecture by Tiziana Piras, Associate Professor of Italian Literature at the University of Trieste, held on Tuesday 17 November at the Antico Caffè San Marco in Trieste. Entitled “Humans and Nature in Literature: A Difficult Relationship”, the event was organised by the “Società Internazionale di divulgazione Manlio Cecovini” Cultural Association.
Through an exploration combining philosophy, the history of ideas and literary criticism, Piras traced the origins of the separation between human beings and other living species, demonstrating how literature can challenge a worldview based on the presumed superiority of humankind. Her analysis focused particularly on the works of three writers closely associated with the mountains – Mario Rigoni Stern, Mauro Corona and Matteo Righetto – whose writing presents nature and animals not merely as a backdrop to human affairs, but as beings with their own identity and dignity.
The lecture began with an introduction to literary ecology, or ecocriticism, a critical approach that examines the relationship between literature and the environment, viewing the latter not as a passive setting but as an essential element of storytelling. Piras then explored the philosophical roots of Western anthropocentrism, contrasting Aristotle’s hierarchical conception, which placed humans above other living beings, with the ideas of Pythagoras and Plutarch, who advocated continuity between different forms of life. This separation was subsequently reinforced by medieval theology and Descartes’ conception of animals as machines, although it was challenged by thinkers such as Montaigne and Voltaire.
The discussion moved on to the emergence of anti-speciesist thought and Human–Animal Studies, which recognise animals not simply as objects at humanity’s disposal, but as beings capable of acting and participating in the relationships that shape the world. From this perspective, literature plays a fundamental role through its ability to transform the way we perceive reality. Through defamiliarisation, a narrative technique that allows familiar situations to be viewed from unexpected perspectives, writing can bring readers closer to the experiences of other living beings, moving beyond an exclusively human viewpoint. One example highlighted by Piras was Giacomo Leopardi’s Operette morali (Moral Essays), which questions humanity’s presumed centrality in the universe.
The second part of the lecture focused on Italian mountain literature, examining the works of Mario Rigoni Stern, Mauro Corona and Matteo Righetto, three authors who, despite their different sensibilities, have portrayed the complexity of the relationship between humans and nature.
For Mario Rigoni Stern, whose life was deeply rooted in the Asiago Plateau and shaped by his experiences of war and imprisonment, knowledge of nature stems from direct observation of forests, animals and the rhythms of the seasons. Hunting, which features in his writing, is not portrayed as an exercise of domination, but as an activity requiring knowledge, restraint and responsibility towards the balance of nature. Particularly significant was the reference to Il bosco degli urogalli, in which the killing of a capercaillie causes the hunter profound moral distress: the animal is not merely prey, but a living creature whose death confronts the human being with responsibility for his actions.
With Mauro Corona, a more painful and conflict-ridden portrayal emerges. Having grown up in the forests of Erto, Corona has built much of his literary work around memories of mountain life and the Vajont disaster, interpreted as a dramatic manifestation of human arrogance towards nature. In Il volo della martora, through an imaginary dialogue between mountains, Corona denounces the presumption of a science and technology incapable of recognising the limits imposed by the environment. His relationship with animals is also marked by remorse over childhood hunting experiences, while in works such as Cani, camosci, cuculi (e un corvo), animals emerge as beings endowed with sensitivity and intelligence. Particularly emblematic was the reference to animal behaviour in the hours preceding the Vajont disaster, when, according to the writer’s account, signs of distress among animals went unheeded by humans.
The literary journey concluded with Matteo Righetto, whose work develops a more explicitly ecological reflection based on the interdependence of all forms of life. In Il passo del vento, co-written with Corona, Rigoni Stern is compared to a larch tree, symbolising wisdom, patience and respect for nature’s rhythms. In La pelle dell’orso, by contrast, an animal initially portrayed as a monstrous creature gradually loses this threatening image when confronted with the devastation caused by the Vajont disaster: the true destructive force is revealed to be human arrogance. Finally, I prati dopo di noipresents a conception of life in which human beings form part of a single system, inseparably connected to the animal, plant and mineral worlds.
In her concluding remarks, Piras emphasised how the three writers, from different perspectives, contribute to overcoming a conception of nature as merely a resource available for human use. In Rigoni Stern’s work, knowledge and respect for natural balances prevail; in Corona’s, guilt and the search for reconciliation; and in Righetto’s, a more radical critique of anthropocentrism and an awareness of the interdependence of all forms of life.
Literature thus becomes a means of understanding and fostering responsibility, capable of challenging established beliefs and recognising animals not as beings subordinate to human needs, but as fellow inhabitants of the world, possessing dignity of their own. It is an invitation to rediscover a sense of proportion in our actions and to understand that humanity’s fate is inseparable from that of the natural world to which it belongs.